[ICCV'21] Pri3D: Can 3D Priors Help 2D Representation Learning?

Overview

Pri3D: Can 3D Priors Help 2D Representation Learning? [ICCV 2021]

Pri3D

Pri3D leverages 3D priors for downstream 2D image understanding tasks: during pre-training, we incorporate view-invariant and geometric priors from color-geometry information given by RGB-D datasets, imbuing geometric priors into learned features. We show that these 3D-imbued learned features can effectively transfer to improved performance on 2D tasks such as semantic segmentation, object detection, and instance segmentation.

[ICCV 2021 Paper] [Video]

Environment

This codebase was tested with the following environment configurations.

Installation

We use conda for the installation process:

# Install virtual env and PyTorch
conda create -n sparseconv051 python=3.8
conda activate sparseconv051
conda install pytorch==1.7.1 torchvision==0.8.2 cudatoolkit=11.0 -c pytorch

# Complie and install MinkowskiEngine 0.5.1.
conda install mkl mkl-include -c intel
wget https://github.com/NVIDIA/MinkowskiEngine/archive/refs/tags/v0.5.1.zip
cd MinkowskiEngine-0.5.1 
python setup.py install

Next, clone the Pri3D repository and install the requirement from the root directory.

git clone https://github.com/Sekunde/Pri3D.git
cd Pri3D
pip install -r requirements.txt

Training Mask R-CNN models requires Detectron2.

[Logging] Pri3D will create runs for logging training curves and configurations in the project named pri3d in Weights & Biases. Additionally, checkpoints and a txt log file will be stored in the specified output folder. You will be asked to input username and password of Weights & Biases in the first time to run the training code.

[Optional] If you want to pre-train the view-consistent contrastive loss on MegaDepth data, you need to install COLMAP, see their installation ducomentation.

Pre-training Section

Data Pre-processing

Prepare ScanNet Pre-training Data

For pre-training view-invariant contrastive loss, pairs of ScanNet frames data can be generated by the following code (need to change the TARGET and SCANNET_DIR accordingly in the script). This piece of code first extracts pointcloud from partial frames, and then computes a filelist of overlapped partial frames for each scene.

cd pretrain/data_preprocess/scannet
./preprocess.sh

Then a combined txt file called overlap30.txt of filelists of each scene can be generated by running the following code. This overlap30.txt should be put into folder TARGET/splits.

cd pretrain/data_preprocess/scannet
python generate_list.py --target_dir TARGET

For pre-training geometric-prior, we first generate point cloud of ScanNet reconstruction. This can be done by running following code. We use SCANNET_DATA to refer where scannet data lives and SCANNET_OUT_PATH to denote the output path of processed scannet data.

# Edit path variables: SCANNET_DATA and SCANNET_OUT_PATH
cd pretrain/data_preprocess/scannet
python collect_indoor3d_data.py --input SCANNET_DATA --output SCANNET_OUT_PATH
# copy the filelists
cp -r split SCANNET_OUT_PATH

Afterwards, we further generate chunk bbox that is used for cropping chunks by running following code. TARGET points to where the previously generated pairs of ScanNet frames are located.

cd pretrain/data_preprocess/scannet/
python chunk.py --base TARGET

Prepare MegaDepth Pre-training Data

We borrow the MegaDepth data generation code from D2-Net. After installing COLMAP and downloading the MegaDepth Dataset(including SfM models), you can run the following code to pre-process data.

cd pretrain/data_preprocess/megadepth/
python undistort_reconstructions.py --colmap_path /path/to/colmap/executable --base_path /path/to/megadepth
bash preprocess_undistorted_megadepth.sh /path/to/megadepth /path/to/output/folder

We also provide visualization of the MegaDepth data.

Prepare KITTI Pre-training Data

Download KITTI Dataset and run the following code to pre-process the data. This will create an overlap.txt file indexing the pairs of frames as well as a mapping folder storing the coordinates mapping between frames located in /path/to/kitti/dataset.

cd pretrain/data_preprocess/kitti/
python kitti_process.py --input /path/to/kitti/dataset

Pre-training on Different Datasets

To pre-train on different datasets, we provide the scripts to train Pri3D with 8 GPUs (batch_size=64, 8 per GPU) on a single server under folder pretrain/pri3d/scripts. Pri3D can also be pre-trained on the server with fewer GPUs, e.g. 4 GPUs by setting train.batsh_size=32 (8 per GPUs) and optimizer.accumulate_step=2 (effective batch_size=32x2=64) to accumulate gradients. The code is competitable with facebook hydra. Our codebase enables multi-gpu training with distributed data parallel (DDP) module in pytorch.

Pre-train on ScanNet

TARGET and SCANNET_OUT_PATH refer to the pre-processed data locations that are defined in Prepare ScanNet Pre-train Data.

cd pretrain/pri3d
export DATAPATH=TARGET 
# if pre-train with geometric-contrastive loss
export POINTCLOUD_PATH=SCANNET_OUT_PATH
# Pretrain with view-invariant loss (ResNet50 backbone)
LOG_DIR=/path/to/log/folder BACKBONE=Res50UNet VIEW=True scripts/scannet.sh
# Pretrain with geometric-contrastive loss (ResNet50 backbone)
LOG_DIR=/path/to/log/folder BACKBONE=Res50UNet GEO=True scripts/scannet.sh
# Pretrain with view-invariant and geometric-contrastive loss (ResNet50 backbone)
LOG_DIR=/path/to/log/folder BACKBONE=Res50UNet VIEW=True GEO=True scripts/scannet.sh
# Pretrain with view-invariant loss (ResNet18 backbone)
LOG_DIR=/path/to/log/folder BACKBONE=Res18UNet VIEW=True scripts/scannet.sh

Pre-train on MegaDepth

cd pretrain/pri3d
export DATAPATH=/path/to/megadepth/processed/data/folder
# Pretrain with view-invariant loss (ResNet50 backbone)
LOG_DIR=/path/to/log/folder BACKBONE=Res50UNet scripts/megadepth.sh
# Pretrain with view-invariant loss (ResNet18 backbone)
LOG_DIR=/path/to/log/folder BACKBONE=Res18UNet scripts/megadepth.sh

Pre-train on KITTI

cd pretrain/pri3d
export DATAPATH=KITTI_PATH
# Pretrain with view-invariant loss (ResNet50 backbone)
LOG_DIR=/path/to/log/folder BACKBONE=Res50UNet scripts/kitti.sh
# Pretrain with view-invariant loss (ResNet18 backbone)
LOG_DIR=/path/to/log/folder BACKBONE=Res18UNet scripts/kitti.sh

Downstream Task Section

Semantic Segmentation on ScanNet

Download scannet_frames_25k and unzip to SCANNET_SEMSEG. It should have following structures.

SCANNET_SEMSEG/
    scene0000_00/
        color/
	depth/
	instance/
	label/
	pose/
	intrinsics_color.txt
	intrinsics_depth.txt
    scene0000_01/
    ...

Export path SCANNET_SEMSEG to enviromental variable $DATAPATH and run the code to train the ResUNet models.

cd downstream/semseg/unet
export DATAPATH=SCANNET_SEMSEG
export PHASE=train
# train the model with ResNet50 backbone, initialized with ImageNet pre-trained model
LOG_DIR=/path/to/log/folder BACKBONE=Res50UNet INIT=imagenet scripts/scannet.sh
# train the model with ResNet50 backbone, train from scratch 
LOG_DIR=/path/to/log/folder BACKBONE=Res50UNet INIT=scratch scripts/scannet.sh
# train the model with ResNet50 backbone, train from scratch with 20% data.
LOG_DIR=/path/to/log/folder BACKBONE=Res50UNet INIT=scratch PHASE=train20 scripts/scannet.sh
# train the model with ResNet50 backbone, initialized with specified pre-trained model
LOG_DIR=/path/to/log/folder BACKBONE=Res50UNet INIT=/path/to/saved/model scripts/scannet.sh
# train the model with ResNet18 backbone, initialized with ImageNet pre-trained model
LOG_DIR=/path/to/log/folder BACKBONE=Res18UNet INIT=imagenet scripts/scannet.sh

Similarly, export environmental variable and run the code to train PSPNet and DeepLabV3/V3+ models.

# train PSPNet (ResNet50 as backbones)
cd downstream/semseg/pspnet
export DATAPATH=SCANNET_SEMSEG
# train PSPNet with ResNet50 backbone, initialized with ImageNet pre-trained model
LOG_DIR=/path/to/log/folder INIT=imagenet scripts/scannet.sh
# train PSPNet with ResNet50 backbone, initialized with specified pre-trained model
LOG_DIR=/path/to/log/folder INIT=/path/to/checkpoint scripts/scannet.sh

# train DeepLabV3 and DeepLabV3+ models (ResNet50 as backbones)
cd downstream/semseg/deeblabv3
export DATAPATH=SCANNET_SEMSEG
# train DeepLabV3 with ResNet50 backbone, initialized with ImageNet pre-trained model
LOG_DIR=/path/to/log/folder INIT=imagenet scripts/train_scannet_deeplapv3.sh
# train DeepLabV3+ with ResNet50 backbone, initialized with ImageNet pre-trained model
LOG_DIR=/path/to/log/folder INIT=imagenet scripts/train_scannet_deeplapv3plus.sh
# train DeepLabV3+ with ResNet50 backbone, initialized with specified pre-trained model
LOG_DIR=/path/to/log/folder INIT=/path/to/checkpoint scripts/train_scannet_deeplabv3plus.sh

Model Zoo

PSPNet and DeepLabV3/V3+ use checkpoints in torchvision format, thus we provide the code for converting from our Pri3D pre-trained checkpoint to torchvision checkpoint.

cd downstream/conversion
python pri3d_to_torchvision.py /path/to/pre-trained/pri3d/checkpoint /path/to/output/checkpoint/in/torchvison/format

The provided pre-trained models for PSPNet and DeepLabV3/V3+ are already converted to torchvision format.

Training Data mIoU (val) Backbone Pre-trained Model (on ScanNet) Curves Logs
100% scenes 61.7 ResNet50 Pri3D (View + Geo) link link
100% scenes 55.7 ResNet18 Pri3D (View + Geo) link link
100% scenes 62.8 PSPNet Pri3D (View + Geo) link link
100% scenes 61.3 DeepLabV3 Pri3D (View + Geo) link link
100% scenes 61.6 DeepLabV3+ Pri3D (View + Geo) link link
80% scenes 60.3 ResNet50 Pri3D (View + Geo) link link
60% scenes 58.9 ResNet50 Pri3D (View + Geo) link link
40% scenes 56.2 ResNet50 Pri3D (View + Geo) link link
20% scenes 51.5 ResNet50 Pri3D (View + Geo) link link

Semantic Segmentation on KITTI

Download and unzip label for semantic and instance segmentation. unzip and organize the data folder as following structures.

KITTI_SESEG/
    image_2/
    instance/
    semantic/
    semantic_rgb/

Use following code snippets to train semantic segmentation models on KITTI data.

cd downstream/semseg
export DATAPATH=KITTI_SEMSEG
# train the model with ResNet50 backbone, initialized with ImageNet pre-trained model
LOG_DIR=/path/to/log/folder BACKBONE=Res50UNet INIT=imagenet scripts/kitti.sh
# train the model with ResNet50 backbone, train from scratch 
LOG_DIR=/path/to/log/folder BACKBONE=Res50UNet INIT=scratch scripts/kitti.sh
# train the model with ResNet50 backbone, initialized with specified pre-trained model
LOG_DIR=/path/to/log/folder BACKBONE=Res50UNet INIT=/path/to/saved/model scripts/kitti.sh
# train the model with ResNet18 backbone, initialized with ImageNet pre-trained model
LOG_DIR=/path/to/log/folder BACKBONE=Res18UNet INIT=imagenet scripts/kitti.sh

Model Zoo

Training Data mIoU (val) Backbone Pre-trained Model Curves Logs
100% scenes 33.2 ResNet50 Pri3D (View) on KITTI link link

Semantic Segmentation on NYUv2

Download NYUv2 Dataset and unzip it to path NYUv2_SEMSEG.

cd downstream/semseg
export DATAPATH=NYUv2_SEMSEG
# train the model with ResNet50 backbone, initialized with ImageNet pre-trained model
LOG_DIR=/path/to/log/folder BACKBONE=Res50UNet INIT=imagenet scripts/nyuv2.sh
# train the model with ResNet50 backbone, train from scratch 
LOG_DIR=/path/to/log/folder BACKBONE=Res50UNet INIT=scratch scripts/nyuv2.sh
# train the model with ResNet50 backbone, initialized with specified pre-trained model
LOG_DIR=/path/to/log/folder BACKBONE=Res50UNet INIT=/path/to/saved/model scripts/nyuv2.sh
# train the model with ResNet18 backbone, initialized with ImageNet pre-trained model
LOG_DIR=/path/to/log/folder BACKBONE=Res18UNet INIT=imagenet scripts/nyuv2.sh

Model Zoo

Training Data mIoU (val) Backbone Pre-trained Model (on ScanNet) Curves Logs
100% scenes 54.7 ResNet50 Pri3D (View + Geo) link link
100% scenes 47.6 ResNet50 MoCoV2-supIN->SN link link

Semantic Segmentation on Cityscapes

Download gtFine_trainvaltest and leftImg8bit_trainvaltest. Unzip and organize as following data structures.

CityScapes_SEMSEG/
    gtFine/
    leftImg8bit/

Export the data path (CityScapes_SEMSEG) to $DATAPATH environmental variable and train the models.

cd downstream/semseg
export DATAPATH=Cityscapes_SEMSEG
# train the model with ResNet50 backbone, initialized with ImageNet pre-trained model
LOG_DIR=/path/to/log/folder BACKBONE=Res50UNet INIT=imagenet scripts/cityscapes.sh
# train the model with ResNet50 backbone, train from scratch 
LOG_DIR=/path/to/log/folder BACKBONE=Res50UNet INIT=scratch scripts/cityscapes.sh
# train the model with ResNet50 backbone, initialized with specified pre-trained model
LOG_DIR=/path/to/log/folder BACKBONE=Res50UNet INIT=/path/to/saved/model scripts/cityscapes.sh
# train the model with ResNet18 backbone, initialized with ImageNet pre-trained model
LOG_DIR=/path/to/log/folder BACKBONE=Res18UNet INIT=imagenet scripts/cityscapes.sh

Model Zoo

Training Data mIoU (val) Backbone Pre-trained Model Curves Logs
100% scenes 56.3 ResNet50 Pri3D (View) on KITTI link link
100% scenes 55.2 ResNet50 Pri3D (View) on MegaDepth link link

Instance Segmentation/Detection on ScanNet

For training an instance segmentation/detection model, a COCO format json file of annotation needs to be generated. We provide code to convert the ScanNet Annotation into COCO format (json file). Path SCANNET_SEMSEG refers to the location of ScanNet semantic segmentation data.

cd downstream/insseg/dataset
# generate json file of annotations for training
python scanet2coco.py --scannet_path SCANNET_SEMSEG --phase train
# generate json file of annotations for validation
python scanet2coco.py --scannet_path SCANNET_SEMSEG --phase val
# generate json file of annotations for training on 20%,40%,60%,80% data.
python scanet2coco.py --scannet_path SCANNET_SEMSEG --phase train20
python scanet2coco.py --scannet_path SCANNET_SEMSEG --phase train40
python scanet2coco.py --scannet_path SCANNET_SEMSEG --phase train60
python scanet2coco.py --scannet_path SCANNET_SEMSEG --phase train80

The code above generates json files, such as scannet_train.coco.json and scannet_val.coco.json. After having json files, the following code will train Mask R-CNN models.

cd downstream/insseg
export JSON_PATH=/path/to/json/file
export IMAGE_PATH=SCANNET_SEMSEG
# train the model with ImageNet pre-trained model 
LOG_DIR=/path/to/log/folder INIT=imagenet sbatch script/train_scannet.sh
# train the model with pre-trained model (remove 'sbatch' if training on a local machine)
LOG_DIR=/path/to/log/folder INIT=/path/to/model sbatch script/train_scannet.sh
# train the model on ScanNet 20% data
JSON_PATH=/path/to/scannet_train20.coco.json LOG_DIR=/path/to/log/folder INIT=imagenet script/train_scannet.sh

Model Zoo

Detectron2 requires a specific checkpoint format, thus we provide the code for converting from our Pri3D pre-trained checkpoint to the required checkpoint format.

cd downstream/conversion
python pri3d_to_torchvision.py /path/to/pri3d/format/checkpoint /path/to//torchvison/format/checkpoint
ptthon torchvision_to_detectron.py /path/to//torchvison/format/checkpoint /path/to/detectron/format/checkpoint

The provided pre-trained models in the following are already converted to detectron2 checkpoints.

Data [email protected] (bbox) [email protected] (segm) Backbone Pre-trained Model (on ScanNet) Curves Logs
100% 44.5 35.8 ResNet50 Pri3D (View + Geo) link link
100% 43.5 33.9 ResNet50 MoCoV2-supIN->SN link link

Instance Segmentation/Detection on NYUv2

Similarly to ScanNet, we provide code to convert the NYUv2 Annotation into COCO format (json files). Path NYUv2_SEMSEG refers to the location of NYUv2 semantic segmentation data.

cd downstream/insseg/dataset
# generate json file of annotations for training
python nyu2coco.py --nyu_path NYUv2_SEMSEG --phase train
# generate json file of annotations for validation
python nyu2coco.py --scannet_path NYUv2_SEMSEG --phase val

The code above generates json files, such as nyu_train.coco.json and nyu_val.coco.json. After having json files, the following code will train Mask R-CNN models.

cd downstream/insseg
export JSON_PATH=/path/to/json/file
export IMAGE_PATH=NYUv2_SEMSEG
# train the model with ImageNet pre-trained model 
LOG_DIR=/path/to/log/folder INIT=imagenet sbatch script/train_nyu.sh
# train the model with pre-trained model (remove 'sbatch' if training on a local machine)
LOG_DIR=/path/to/log/folder INIT=/path/to/model sbatch script/train_nyu.sh

Model Zoo

The provided pre-trained models in the following are already converted to Detectron2 checkpoints (convert to detectrion2 shows how to convert from Pri3D checkpoint to Detectron2 format).

Data [email protected] (bbox) [email protected] (segm) Backbone Pre-trained Model (on ScanNet) Curves Logs
100% 34.0 29.5 ResNet50 Pri3D (View + Geo) link link
100% 31.1 27.2 ResNet50 MoCoV2-supIN->SN link link

Instance Segmentation/Detection on COCO

Download 2017 Train Images, 2017 Val Images and 2017 Train/Val Annotations. Unzip and organize them as following structures.

$DETECTRON2_DATASETS/
    coco/
        annotations/
	    instances_{train,val}2017.json
        {train,val}2017/		

Then using the following code to train instance segmentation/detection models.

cd downstream/insseg
export DETECTRON2_DATASETS=/path/to/datasets
# train the model with ImageNet pre-trained model 
LOG_DIR=/path/to/log/folder INIT=imagenet sbatch script/train_coco.sh
# train the model with pre-trained model (remove 'sbatch' if training on a local machine)
LOG_DIR=/path/to/log/folder INIT=/path/to/model sbatch script/train_coco.sh

Model Zoo

The provided pre-trained models in the following are already converted to Detectron2 checkpoints (convert to detectron2 shows how to convert from Pri3D checkpoint to Detectron2 format).

Data [email protected] (bbox) [email protected] (segm) Backbone Pre-trained Model (on ScanNet) Curves Logs
100% 60.6 57.5 ResNet50 Pri3D (View) link link

Citing our paper

@article{hou2021pri3d,
  title={Pri3D: Can 3D Priors Help 2D Representation Learning?},
  author={Hou, Ji and Xie, Saining and Graham, Benjamin and Dai, Angela and Nie{\ss}ner, Matthias},
  journal={arXiv preprint arXiv:2104.11225},
  year={2021}
}

License

Pri3D is relased under the MIT License. See the LICENSE file for more details.

Owner
Ji Hou
PhD Candidate in TUM
Ji Hou
Template repository to build PyTorch projects from source on any version of PyTorch/CUDA/cuDNN.

The Ultimate PyTorch Source-Build Template Translations: 한국어 TL;DR PyTorch built from source can be x4 faster than a naïve PyTorch install. This repos

Joonhyung Lee/이준형 651 Dec 12, 2022
A library for augmentation of a YOLO-formated dataset

YOLO Dataset Augmentation lib Инструкция по использованию этой библиотеки Запуск всех файлов осуществлять из консоли. GoogleCrawl_to_Dataset.py Это ск

Egor Orel 1 Dec 10, 2022
Tutoriais publicados nas nossas redes sociais para obtenção de dados, análises simples e outras tarefas relevantes no mercado financeiro.

Tutoriais Públicos Tutoriais publicados nas nossas redes sociais para obtenção de dados, análises simples e outras tarefas relevantes no mercado finan

Trading com Dados 68 Oct 15, 2022
Official TensorFlow code for the forthcoming paper

~ Efficient-CapsNet ~ Are you tired of over inflated and overused convolutional neural networks? You're right! It's time for CAPSULES :)

Vittorio Mazzia 203 Jan 08, 2023
[CVPR 2021] Region-aware Adaptive Instance Normalization for Image Harmonization

RainNet — Official Pytorch Implementation Region-aware Adaptive Instance Normalization for Image Harmonization Jun Ling, Han Xue, Li Song*, Rong Xie,

130 Dec 11, 2022
Fully Adaptive Bayesian Algorithm for Data Analysis (FABADA) is a new approach of noise reduction methods. In this repository is shown the package developed for this new method based on \citepaper.

Fully Adaptive Bayesian Algorithm for Data Analysis FABADA FABADA is a novel non-parametric noise reduction technique which arise from the point of vi

18 Oct 20, 2022
Mouse Brain in the Model Zoo

Deep Neural Mouse Brain Modeling This is the repository for the ongoing deep neural mouse modeling project, an attempt to characterize the representat

Colin Conwell 15 Aug 22, 2022
Multi-robot collaborative exploration and mapping through Voronoi partition and DRL in unknown environment

Voronoi Multi_Robot Collaborate Exploration Introduction In the unknown environment, the cooperative exploration of multiple robots is completed by Vo

PeaceWord 6 Nov 22, 2022
The official implementation of paper Siamese Transformer Pyramid Networks for Real-Time UAV Tracking, accepted by WACV22

SiamTPN Introduction This is the official implementation of the SiamTPN (WACV2022). The tracker intergrates pyramid feature network and transformer in

Robotics and Intelligent Systems Control @ NYUAD 28 Nov 25, 2022
Transfer style api - An API to use with Tranfer Style App, where you can use two image and transfer the style

Transfer Style API It's an API to use with Tranfer Style App, where you can use

Brian Alejandro 1 Feb 13, 2022
PyTorch Implementation of [1611.06440] Pruning Convolutional Neural Networks for Resource Efficient Inference

PyTorch implementation of [1611.06440 Pruning Convolutional Neural Networks for Resource Efficient Inference] This demonstrates pruning a VGG16 based

Jacob Gildenblat 836 Dec 26, 2022
Code for IntraQ, PyTorch implementation of our paper under review

IntraQ: Learning Synthetic Images with Intra-Class Heterogeneity for Zero-Shot Network Quantization paper Requirements Python = 3.7.10 Pytorch == 1.7

1 Nov 19, 2021
CPU inference engine that delivers unprecedented performance for sparse models

The DeepSparse Engine is a CPU runtime that delivers unprecedented performance by taking advantage of natural sparsity within neural networks to reduce compute required as well as accelerate memory b

Neural Magic 1.2k Jan 09, 2023
Pytorch Lightning code guideline for conferences

Deep learning project seed Use this seed to start new deep learning / ML projects. Built in setup.py Built in requirements Examples with MNIST Badges

Pytorch Lightning 1k Jan 02, 2023
Python implementation of 3D facial mesh exaggeration using the techniques described in the paper: Computational Caricaturization of Surfaces.

Python implementation of 3D facial mesh exaggeration using the techniques described in the paper: Computational Caricaturization of Surfaces.

Wonjong Jang 8 Nov 01, 2022
This project is the PyTorch implementation of our CVPR 2022 paper:

Requirements and Dependency Install PyTorch with CUDA (for GPU). (Experiments are validated on python 3.8.11 and pytorch 1.7.0) (For visualization if

Lei Huang 23 Nov 29, 2022
simple demo codes for Learning to Teach with Dynamic Loss Functions

Learning to Teach with Dynamic Loss Functions This repo contains the simple demo for the NeurIPS-18 paper: Learning to Teach with Dynamic Loss Functio

Lijun Wu 15 Dec 30, 2021
A Genetic Programming platform for Python with TensorFlow for wicked-fast CPU and GPU support.

Karoo GP Karoo GP is an evolutionary algorithm, a genetic programming application suite written in Python which supports both symbolic regression and

Kai Staats 149 Jan 09, 2023
Predict and time series avocado hass

RECOMMENDER SYSTEM MARKETING TỔNG QUAN VỀ HỆ THỐNG DỮ LIỆU 1. Giới thiệu - Tiki là một hệ sinh thái thương mại "all in one", trong đó có tiki.vn, là

hieulmsc 3 Jan 10, 2022
Athena is the only tool that you will ever need to optimize your portfolio.

Athena Portfolio optimization is the process of selecting the best portfolio (asset distribution), out of the set of all portfolios being considered,

Indrajit 1 Mar 25, 2022